Yeti Rambler vs Stanley Quencher: Which is better?
How does Stanley compare to Yeti? Project Farm experts put Stanley, Yeti, and 12 other popular tumblers through rigorous testing,, evaluating their hot and cold temperature efficiency, splash and spill proof performance, tip over angle, lid ergonomics, corrosion resistance, and lid durability. To help you find the best tumbler for your needs.
Stanley vs Yeti Comparison: The Video Review
To save you time, I’ve summarized the results for Stanley and Yeti below.
| Brands | Stanley | Yeti |
|---|---|---|
| Cold Temperature Performance After 5 Hours | A+ | A |
| Temperature of Water in Tumbler After 5 hours in -40C/-40F Freezer | A+
| B+
|
| Tip Over Angle | A-
| A+
|
| Subjective Spill and Splash Rating | A | B |
| Subjective Leak Proof Rating | B | B |
| Force to Open Slider or Flip Lid | B+
| A+
|
| Subjective Lid Cover "Ease of Use Rating" | B+
| A+
|
| Lid Durability Rating | A+
| A+
|
| Subjective Rating of Ability to Contain Water After Impactiong Concrete Floor From 30 Inches | A
| D |
| Subjective Corrosion Reisitance Rating | A+
| B |
| Check Price and Customer Reviews on Amazon |
The tests revealed strong performances from both Stanley and Yeti, but Stanley came out on top overall. Stanley excelled in 6 key metrics, while Yeti led in just 3. Notably, Yeti received the lowest grade, a “D,” in the “Ability to Contain Water After Impacting Concrete Floor From 30 Inches” test.
Bottom line: Based on the results, Stanley is the better choice.
- OPTIMAL SIZE, MAXIMUM COMFORT: Enjoy leisurely mornings on your patio with the Stay Hot Camp Mug. Designed to provide legendary Stanley performance, it’s just the right fit for cozy moments. Whether…
- SIP WITH CONFIDENCE: The secure press-fit Tritan Drink-Thru Lid ensures your sips are splash-free and hassle-free. Not only does it lock in the temperature, but it also prevents those annoying…
- THERMAL PERFORMANCE: With Stanley’s double-wall vacuum insulation, you can count on your drinks staying at the perfect temperature. Your morning brew will stay hot for up to 1.5 hours. For those…
- YOUR DREAM TUMBLER: Whichever way your day flows, the H2.0 FlowState tumbler keeps you refreshed with fewer refills. Double wall vacuum insulation means drinks stay cold, iced or hot for hours. Choose…
- ADVANCED LID CONSTRUCTION: Whether you prefer small sips or maximum thirst quenching, Stanley has developed an advanced FlowState lid, featuring a rotating cover with three positions: a straw opening…
- EARTH-FRIENDLY DURABILITY: Constructed of 90% recycled BPA free stainless steel for sustainable sipping, the Stanley Quencher H2.0 has the durability to stand up to a lifetime of use. Eliminate the…
- YOUR DREAM TUMBLER: Whichever way your day flows, the H2.0 FlowState tumbler keeps you refreshed with fewer refills. Double wall vacuum insulation means drinks stay cold, iced or hot for hours. Choose…
- ADVANCED LID CONSTRUCTION: Whether you prefer small sips or maximum thirst quenching, Stanley has developed an advanced FlowState lid, featuring a rotating cover with three positions: a straw opening…
- EARTH-FRIENDLY DURABILITY: Constructed of 90% recycled BPA free stainless steel for sustainable sipping, the Stanley Quencher H2.0 has the durability to stand up to a lifetime of use. Eliminate the…
That said, both tumblers are excellent and more than capable of meeting your everyday needs. In reality, unless you’re laser-focused on specific performance details, you’re unlikely to notice a significant difference in daily use. For most people, minor performance differences shouldn’t be the deciding factor when choosing a tumbler.
When it comes to everyday items like tumblers, design and the values a brand represents often take center stage. Choosing a tumbler is like picking out clothes—it’s about personal taste, aesthetics, and the joy of expressing yourself through the things you use daily.
Both Yeti and Stanley put a lot of thought into their designs, they each offer over 30 colors and multiple sizes to cater to a variety of preferences. Stanley, however, stands out with a broader range of size options and a sleek, stylish design that has made it a favorite among users. It’s no surprise that Stanley has consistently been the best-selling brand in Amazon’s Home & Kitchen category (Check the Amazon Best Sellers List).
- YOUR DREAM TUMBLER: Whichever way your day flows, the H2.0 FlowState tumbler keeps you refreshed with fewer refills. Double wall vacuum insulation means drinks stay cold, iced or hot for hours. Choose…
- ADVANCED LID CONSTRUCTION: Whether you prefer small sips or maximum thirst quenching, Stanley has developed an advanced FlowState lid, featuring a rotating cover with three positions: a straw opening…
- EARTH-FRIENDLY DURABILITY: Constructed of 90% recycled BPA free stainless steel for sustainable sipping, the Stanley Quencher H2.0 has the durability to stand up to a lifetime of use. Eliminate the…
- These Ramblers come standard with our YETI MagSlider Lid, the only drink lid that uses the power of magnets to keep your water, beer, or favorite drink on lock
- Our Ramblers are BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and have a No Sweat Design to make sure your hands stay dry
- Dracut is a durable coat of color that won’t fade, peel, or crack through extended field use and also provide additional grip to the Rambler’s exterior
Stanley vs Yeti: How to Choose?
If performance is your top priority, refer to the test results above or watch the video for all the details—Stanley outshines Yeti in most categories.
If, like me, you value design and style, I recommend browsing Amazon to compare the two brands’ tumblers and picking the one that best matches your taste.
Plus, customer reviews on Amazon are an excellent resource to help you make a decision.
- YOUR DREAM TUMBLER: Whichever way your day flows, the H2.0 FlowState tumbler keeps you refreshed with fewer refills. Double wall vacuum insulation means drinks stay cold, iced or hot for hours. Choose…
- ADVANCED LID CONSTRUCTION: Whether you prefer small sips or maximum thirst quenching, Stanley has developed an advanced FlowState lid, featuring a rotating cover with three positions: a straw opening…
- EARTH-FRIENDLY DURABILITY: Constructed of 90% recycled BPA free stainless steel for sustainable sipping, the Stanley Quencher H2.0 has the durability to stand up to a lifetime of use. Eliminate the…
- These Ramblers come standard with our YETI MagSlider Lid, the only drink lid that uses the power of magnets to keep your water, beer, or favorite drink on lock
- Our Ramblers are BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and have a No Sweat Design to make sure your hands stay dry
- Dracut is a durable coat of color that won’t fade, peel, or crack through extended field use and also provide additional grip to the Rambler’s exterior
Below is the result of all the products reviewed in the video:
If you’re interested in any of the other products featured, feel free to click the links to explore them on Amazon:
Stanley: Visite Amazon (Recommend!)
Yeti: Visite Amazon (Recommend!)
Hydro Flask: Visite Amazon
HASLE: Visite Amazon
Juro: Visite Amazon
Murricon: Visite Amazon
Klean Kanteen:Visite Amazon
RTIC: Visite Amazon
Tervis Diamond Plate:Visite Amazon (Recommend!)
Coleman: Visite Amazon
Arctic Tumblers: Visite Amazon (Recommend!)
Iron Flask: Visite Amazon (Recommend!)
MiiR: Visite Amazon
CamelBak: Visite Amazon
- ROVER TUMBLER 2.0: Goodbye sweat! The double wall insulation makes the Iron Flask Tumbler sweat-free! It keeps your drink COLD for up to 20 hours, and HOT for up to 5 hours (depending on size). Our…
- 2 LEAKPROOF LIDS: YES, the Second Generation Rover Tumbler comes with TWO insulated lids. A leakproof Straw Lid with 2 Straws, and a leakproof Flip Lid.
- 18/8 PREMIUM STAINLESS STEEL: Iron Flask is made of 18/8 Stainless steel that is BPA free and non-toxic. It will never leave a metal taste or rust. HAND WASH ONLY WITH SOAPY HOT WATER!
- YOUR DREAM TUMBLER: Whichever way your day flows, the H2.0 FlowState tumbler keeps you refreshed with fewer refills. Double wall vacuum insulation means drinks stay cold, iced or hot for hours. Choose…
- ADVANCED LID CONSTRUCTION: Whether you prefer small sips or maximum thirst quenching, Stanley has developed an advanced FlowState lid, featuring a rotating cover with three positions: a straw opening…
- EARTH-FRIENDLY DURABILITY: Constructed of 90% recycled BPA free stainless steel for sustainable sipping, the Stanley Quencher H2.0 has the durability to stand up to a lifetime of use. Eliminate the…
- These Ramblers come standard with our YETI MagSlider Lid, the only drink lid that uses the power of magnets to keep your water, beer, or favorite drink on lock
- Our Ramblers are BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and have a No Sweat Design to make sure your hands stay dry
- Dracut is a durable coat of color that won’t fade, peel, or crack through extended field use and also provide additional grip to the Rambler’s exterior
